Business Hitches Blocking Indian Economic Growth

Author : CA A. K. Jain


-Chapter Headings-

* Preamble
* Composition of Business Difficulties
A. Bureaucratic Red Tape
B. Access to Finance
C. Infrastructure Deficiencies
D. Skill Shortages & Mismatch

* Government Initiatives
A. Ease of Doing Business Reforms :
B. Digitalization of Processes :
C. Infrastructure Development :
D. Financial Support and Incentives: 
E. Skill Development Programs:
F. Policy Reforms and Clarity :
G. Investment Promotion :

* Corporate Failures in India
A. Multinational Companies
1. Retail :
2. Automobile :
3. Manufacturing :
4. Telecommunications :

B. Indian Business :
1. Air Lines :
2. Government Companies :
3. Sugar :
4. Automobile :
5. Diversified Business :

* Conclusion

Preamble

India, with its vast population and diverse resources, holds immense potential for economic growth. However, this potential often encounters hurdles due to various business difficulties plaguing the country's entrepreneurial landscape. From bureaucratic red tape to infrastructure challenges, these obstacles hinder the smooth development of the Indian economy. In this article, we'll explore some of the key business difficulties faced by India and propose solutions to overcome them.


Composition of Business Difficulties

A. Bureaucratic Red Tape : One of the major impediments to business growth in India is the bureaucratic red tape. Cumbersome regulations, lengthy approval processes, and complex tax structures often discourage entrepreneurs from starting or expanding their businesses. This bureaucratic maze not only stifles innovation but also increases the cost of doing business. In India, this has often resulted in inefficiency, stunted economic growth, and frustration among citizens and businesses.

Characteristics of Bureaucratic Red Tape in India :
1. Complex Procedures: Numerous layers of approvals and clearances, often with unclear guidelines.
2. Delays: Extended timeframes for decision-making due to multiple levels of scrutiny.
3. Corruption: Bribes and under-the-table dealings become necessary to expedite processes.
4. Lack of Accountability: No clear responsibility for delays, making it difficult to hold anyone accountable.

Impact of Red Tape on Indian Businesses
Example Description Impact on Business
License Raj (Pre-1991) Businesses required to obtain numerous licenses and permits from various government departments to operate. Stifled entrepreneurship and innovation, causing slow economic growth.
Land Acquisition for Industries Lengthy processes for acquiring land due to multiple clearances needed from various state and central government bodies. Delayed industrial projects, increased costs, and reduced competitiveness.
Environmental Clearances Multiple clearances needed from different environmental bodies for new projects, leading to delays. Held up major infrastructure projects like highways, mining, and energy plants.
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Approval Complex and lengthy procedures to obtain FDI approvals, involving multiple ministries and departments. Discouraged foreign investors, leading to missed opportunities and slower economic growth.
Tax Compliance and Refunds Complicated tax laws and slow processing of tax refunds. Cash flow issues for businesses, particularly SMEs, leading to financial strain and operational delays.

Red tape in India has historically hindered the country’s economic progress and governance. However, recent government initiatives aimed at simplifying procedures, digitizing services, and enhancing transparency are helping to reduce these bureaucratic hurdles. To further combat red tape, a continued focus on regulatory reform, accountability, and the use of technology is essential.

B. Access to Finance : Securing finance is a critical challenge for businesses across sectors in India, especially for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and new entrepreneurs. The problem is multi-faceted, involving issues related to accessibility, affordability, and the complexity of the financial ecosystem. This often leads to business failures, particularly among start-ups and SMEs, which are more vulnerable due to their limited financial resources and lack of collateral.

A few of the pressing challenges are discussed below :
1. Accessibility to Finance : SMEs face difficulties accessing formal finance due to stringent collateral requirements, lack of credit history, and the perception of being high-risk borrowers by financial institutions. While large enterprises have better access to finance, they often face delays in obtaining credit, especially for large-scale projects requiring significant capital investments.

2. High Cost of Capital : Interest rates on loans for SMEs are often higher due to perceived risks, increasing the cost of capital and affecting profitability. New entrepreneurs without a proven track record are often charged higher interest rates or denied credit altogether.

3. Complex Procedures : Lengthy and bureaucratic loan application processes deter many small businesses and start-ups from seeking formal finance. Compliance with regulatory requirements, including extensive documentation, can be overwhelming, especially for first-time entrepreneurs.

4. Lack of Financial Literacy ; Many small business owners and new entrepreneurs lack financial literacy, making it difficult for them to navigate the financial system, assess loan products, or manage finances effectively.

5. Inadequate Government Support : Despite various government schemes, the actual disbursement of funds is often marred by delays, complex eligibility criteria, and inadequate outreach to rural and semi-urban areas.

Impact of Financial Challenges on Business Failure
Sector Problem Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Difficulty in obtaining collateral-free loans and high interest rates. High operational costs, inability to scale, and eventual closure. Many micro-enterprises in rural areas shut down within a year due to a lack of working capital.
Medium Business Lengthy loan approval processes and inadequate funding for expansion. Stalled growth, loss of competitive edge, and risk of insolvency. Manufacturing units in Tier-2 cities face delays in machinery procurement due to slow loan approvals.
Large Business Delays in project financing for capital-intensive ventures. Project delays, cost overruns, and reduced profitability. Infrastructure projects like highways and airports often face delays due to funding bottlenecks.
Startups Lack of seed funding, high cost of debt, and investor reluctance. Early-stage failure due to cash flow problems and inability to sustain operations. Many tech startups fail to survive beyond the initial 2-3 years due to a lack of venture capital.

The difficulty in organizing finance is a significant barrier to business success in India, particularly for small businesses and new entrepreneurs. Despite government initiatives, the challenges of accessibility, high costs, and complex processes persist. Addressing these issues requires a multi-pronged approach, including strengthening alternative financing options, enhancing existing government schemes, improving financial literacy, and reducing the cost of capital.

C. Infrastructure Deficiencies : Infrastructure is a critical enabler for economic growth, business development, and industrial expansion. In India, infrastructure deficiencies pose significant challenges for businesses across all sectors, including small, medium, and large enterprises. Poor infrastructure can lead to increased operational costs, reduced efficiency, and ultimately, business failures, particularly for new entrepreneurs. Key Infrastructure Challenges are discussed below.

1. Transportation and Logistics : Poor road quality, traffic congestion, and inadequate connectivity between rural and urban areas delay the movement of goods and increase logistics costs. Overcrowded and outdated railway infrastructure leads to delays in freight transport, affecting supply chain efficiency. Limited capacity and slow clearance processes at ports increase shipping times and costs, especially for exporters and importers.

2. Power Supply : Frequent power outages and fluctuations disrupt production processes, increasing operational costs due to the need for backup power sources. High electricity tariffs for industrial use burden businesses, particularly in energy-intensive industries like manufacturing.

3. Telecommunications and Digital Infrastructure : Poor internet connectivity, especially in rural and semi-urban areas, hampers business operations especially for those relying on digital platforms. Limited access to high-speed internet and digital tools reduces competitiveness, particularly for SMEs and start-ups.

4. Water Supply and Sanitation : Inadequate water supply affects industries that rely heavily on water, such as textiles, food processing, and chemicals. Inadequate sanitation facilities in industrial areas affect worker health, reducing productivity and increasing absenteeism.

5. Industrial Infrastructure : Lack of well-developed industrial parks and special economic zones (SEZs) with adequate facilities discourages investment and growth in certain regions. Insufficient and poorly maintained warehouses lead to higher storage costs and product wastage.

Impact of Infrastructure Deficiencies on Business Failure
Sector Infrastructure Issue Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Poor road connectivity and unreliable power supply. Delays in product delivery, increased operational costs, and reduced competitiveness. Small manufacturing units in rural areas struggle with high logistics costs due to poor road infrastructure.
Medium Business High electricity tariffs and inadequate water supply. Increased production costs, frequent downtimes, and inability to meet customer demand. Textile units face production halts due to power outages and water shortages, leading to financial losses.
Large Business Inadequate port infrastructure and slow customs clearance. Delays in export/import, increased logistics costs, and missed global market opportunities. Export-oriented units suffer due to slow clearance at ports, affecting global competitiveness.
Startups Limited digital infrastructure and poor internet connectivity. Inability to leverage digital platforms, reduced market reach, and slow business growth. Tech startups in Tier-3 cities face connectivity issues, limiting their ability to scale operations.

Infrastructure deficiencies in India pose significant challenges to businesses across all sectors. While the government has initiated several projects to address these gaps, the slow pace of implementation, regional disparities, and inadequate infrastructure in key areas continue to hinder business growth and success. Addressing these challenges through accelerated infrastructure development, improved digital connectivity, and strategic investments in underdeveloped regions is crucial for creating a more conducive business environment in India.

D. Skill Shortages & Mismatch : Skill shortages are a significant challenge for businesses across all sectors in India, affecting small, medium, and large enterprises alike. The lack of adequately skilled workers hampers productivity, innovation, and growth, leading to increased operational costs and, in some cases, business failure. This issue is particularly acute for new entrepreneurs who often struggle to find the right talent to execute their business strategies effectively. The key Challenges are discussed below.

1. Skill Mismatch : Educational institutions in India often do not equip students with the practical skills required by the industry, leading to a gap between academic qualifications and job requirements. The slow pace of curriculum updates means that many graduates are trained in outdated technologies and methodologies, making them less valuable to modern businesses.

2. Limited Access to Skilled Labour : Businesses in rural and semi-urban areas face more significant challenges in accessing skilled labour compared to those in metropolitan areas, leading to higher operational costs and lower productivity. Skilled workers tend to migrate to urban centres in search of better opportunities, leaving a skill vacuum in less developed areas.

3. High Employee Turnover : High attrition rates, especially in industries like IT and manufacturing, lead to a constant need for retraining and up skilling, increasing costs for businesses.The trend of job hopping for better salaries further exacerbates the problem of skill shortages, particularly for SMEs that cannot match the compensation offered by larger companies.

4. Inadequate Focus on Vocational Training : The emphasis on formal education over vocational training means that many potential workers are not equipped with the practical skills needed in industries like manufacturing, construction, and services. The number of quality vocational training institutes is insufficient to meet the demand for skilled labour, particularly in emerging industries.

Impact of Skill Shortages on Business Failure
Sector Skill Shortage Issue Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Lack of skilled workers in specialized areas like IT and engineering. Inability to complete projects on time, reduced product quality. Small tech firms in Tier-2 cities struggle to find qualified software developers, leading to missed deadlines.
Medium Business High turnover and lack of mid-level management skills. Increased training costs, inefficiency, and stagnation in growth. Manufacturing units face frequent disruptions due to the constant need to replace and train skilled workers.
Large Business Inadequate availability of advanced technical skills for R & D. Reduced innovation, delays in product development, and loss of competitive edge. Large automotive firms face challenges in recruiting engineers skilled in electric vehicle technology.
Startups Inability to attract and retain top talent due to limited resources. Slower growth, inability to scale, and early-stage business failure. Startups in AI and machine learning struggle to compete with established firms for top data scientists.

Government Initiatives

A. Ease of Doing Business Reforms : The Government of India has undertaken numerous reforms aimed at improving the ease of doing business across the country. These reforms are designed to simplify regulatory processes, reduce bureaucratic hurdles, and enhance the overall business environment, thereby supporting entrepreneurs and businesses of all sizes—small, medium, and large. The key Ease of Doing Business reforms are discussed here.

1. Simplification of Regulatory Processes : Goods and Services Tax (GST): Introduced in 2017, GST replaced multiple indirect taxes with a single tax structure, reducing the tax compliance burden on businesses. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) implemented in 2016, the IBC streamlines the resolution of insolvency cases, providing a time-bound process for the recovery of dues by creditors. As part of labour Law reforms, the government has consolidated 29 central labour laws into four codes (wages, industrial relations, social security, and occupational safety) to simplify compliance and reduce litigation.

2. Digital Initiatives : Digital India Campaign promotes the adoption of digital technologies across various sectors, enabling easier access to government services, including registrations, licenses, and tax filings. Online Single Window System is launched to provide a one-stop platform for obtaining all necessary business licenses and permits, reducing the time and effort required for starting a business. Corporate Affairs Ministry's has launched MCA21 Portal to help businessman to comply with corporate law requirements online, reducing paperwork and enhancing transparency.

3. Infrastructure Development : The government has invested heavily in infrastructure projects like the Bharatmala Pariyojana (roads) and Sagarmala (ports) to improve logistics, reducing transportation costs for businesses. Development of industrial corridors like the Delhi-Mumbai Industrial Corridor (DMIC) will provide world-class infrastructure to support manufacturing and trade.

4. Trade Facilitation : The introduction of the Customs EDI (Electronic Data Interchange) system has streamlined customs processes, reducing clearance times for imports and exports. Trade Infrastructure for Export Scheme is launched to upgrade export infrastructure, reduce transaction costs, and enhance the competitiveness of Indian exports.

Impact of Ease of Doing Business Reforms on Different Sectors
Sector Ease of Doing Business Reform. Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Simplification of GST compliance. Reduced tax compliance burden, easier cash flow management, and transparency. Small traders benefit from simplified tax structure under GST, reducing their operational complexities.
Medium Business Adoption of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). Faster resolution of insolvency cases, better access to credit, and improved business viability. Medium-sized enterprises in the manufacturing sector can resolve insolvency issues faster through the IBC.
Large Business Online Single Window System for business licenses. Reduced time and effort in obtaining necessary permits, faster project initiation. Large corporates experience faster project rollouts due to the streamlined licensing process.
Startups Digital India initiatives and MCA21 portal. Easier registration process, reduced paperwork, and quicker compliance. Tech startups leverage digital platforms to complete regulatory requirements online, speeding up operations.

The Government of India’s Ease of Doing Business reforms have significantly improved the business environment, benefiting enterprises across various sectors. By simplifying regulatory processes, improving infrastructure, and promoting digital initiatives, the government has reduced barriers to entry and operational complexities for businesses. However, continued focus on regulatory streamlining, infrastructure development, and skill enhancement is necessary to maintain and further improve the ease of doing business in India.

To address regulatory uncertainty, the government should adopt a stable and predictable policy framework, with clear guidelines and transparent decision-making processes. Engaging stakeholders through consultations and seeking feedback on proposed regulations can help ensure that policies are well-informed and balanced. Moreover, regulatory bodies should focus on efficient enforcement and compliance rather than imposing excessive bureaucratic hurdles.

B. Digitalization of Processes : The Government of India has implemented several digital initiatives to foster a conducive business environment across all sectors, including small, medium, and large enterprises. These initiatives aim to streamline operations, enhance transparency, improve service delivery, and facilitate easier access to government services, thereby reducing the cost and complexity of doing business.

1. Key Initiatives: The key Digital Initiatives are discussed here.

a. Digital India Campaign : Launched in 2015, the Digital India campaign aims to transform India into a digitally empowered society and knowledge economy. The initiative focuses on providing digital infrastructure, digital literacy, and digital services to all citizens and businesses. This includes development of broadband highways, universal access to mobile connectivity, public internet access, digital Governance ( e-Governance) reforms, including online access to government services and e-Kranti (electronic delivery of services), promoting digital literacy and access to digital resources, and Unified Payments Interface system that facilitates instant money transfers between bank accounts via mobile devices. It has revolutionized digital payments in India, making transactions easier for businesses. The key benefits of digital campaign include direct digital payments, lower transaction fees, wider Customer Reach including those in remote areas.

b. Government e-Marketplace (GeM) : GeM is an online platform launched by the Government of India to facilitate procurement of goods and services by government departments, organizations, and PSUs. It is a one-stop-shop for businesses to supply products and services to the government. This ensures a fair and transparent procurement process, simplified registration and bidding process for businesses. This also provides access to government buyers, increasing business opportunities for SMEs.

c. Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) : GSTN is the IT backbone of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system, facilitating the filing of returns, tax payments, and refunds. It has unified India’s indirect tax system, benefiting businesses by simplifying compliance.

d. e-Way Bill System : The e-Way Bill system is an electronic documentation system for the movement of goods across India. It is integrated with the GST system and is mandatory for inter-state and intra-state goods transportation. This facilitates seamless transportation of goods, reducing delays at checkpoints and helps businesses manage logistics more effectively. This also ensures compliance with GST laws, reducing the risk of penalties.

Impact of Digital Initiatives on Different Sectors
Sector Digital Initiative Impact on Business Examples
Small Business UPI for digital payments. Simplified payment collection, reduced cash handling, and broader customer base. Local kirana stores use UPI for quick payments, reducing reliance on cash transactions.
Medium Business GeM for government procurement. Access to government contracts, simplified procurement process, and increased revenue. SMEs supplying office supplies to government departments through GeM platform.
Large Business GSTN for tax compliance. Unified tax structure, reduced compliance burden, and transparency. Large manufacturing firms benefit from streamlined GST compliance, reducing time and costs.
Startups Digital India for infrastructure and UPI for payments. Easy access to digital tools, enhanced customer reach, and efficient financial management. Tech startups leverage digital platforms for operations and payments, ensuring rapid scalability.

Digital Adoption in Business

Digital Initiative Pre-Reform Scenario Post-Reform Scenario Impact on Businesses
UPI Adoption Low adoption of digital payments, high cash dependency. Over 10 billion transactions per month, widespread adoption. Enabled businesses to expand payment options, reduced cash handling, and improved efficiency.
GeM Platform Lengthy and opaque government procurement process. Over 1.2 million sellers and service providers on GeM. Enhanced transparency, increased opportunities for SMEs, and reduced procurement costs.
GST Compliance via GSTN Complex tax structure, multiple filings across states. Simplified tax compliance, single return filing system. Reduced compliance costs, unified market across India, and improved cash flow management.
e-Way Bill Implementation Frequent delays at checkpoints, complex documentation. Digital tracking and faster goods movement across states. Improved supply chain efficiency, reduced transportation time, and lower logistics costs.

2. Suggestions to Enhance Digital Initiatives : Promote digital literacy across all demographics, especially in rural and semi-urban areas, to ensure widespread adoption of digital tools. Enhance security protocols and awareness to build trust in digital systems, particularly in financial transactions. Invest in high-speed internet access in remote areas to ensure that businesses across the country can benefit from digital initiatives.

Conduct targeted awareness campaigns for SMEs and start-ups to educate them on the benefits of digital initiatives and how to leverage them effectively. Ensure seamless integration of various digital platforms (e.g., GSTN, GeM, UPI) to provide businesses with a unified and user-friendly experience.

The digital initiatives undertaken by the Government of India have significantly transformed the business landscape, making it easier for entrepreneurs and businesses of all sizes to operate, scale, and compete in the market. By leveraging digital tools, businesses can improve efficiency, reduce costs, and access new opportunities. Continued focus on expanding digital infrastructure, enhancing cyber security, and promoting digital literacy will be essential to sustaining and building on these gains.

C. Infrastructure Development : Infrastructure development is crucial for fostering business growth and economic development. Recognizing this, the Government of India has implemented several initiatives aimed at improving the country’s infrastructure, benefiting businesses across small, medium, and large sectors. These initiatives focus on transportation, energy, logistics, and urban development, creating an environment conducive to business operations.

Impact of Infrastructure Development on Different Sectors
Sector Infrastructure Initiative Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Bharatmala Pariyojana for road connectivity. Improved access to markets, reduced transportation costs, and enhanced supply chain efficiency. Small manufacturers in remote areas can now reach larger markets faster and at lower costs.
Medium Business Sagarmala Programme for port-led development. Reduced logistics costs, enhanced export-import operations, and increased trade efficiency. Medium-sized exporters benefit from modernized ports and efficient coastal shipping routes.
Large Business Dedicated Freight Corridors for efficient goods transport. Faster transportation of bulk goods, reduced transit times, and lower freight costs. Large manufacturing companies use DFCs for faster movement of goods across states, improving supply chain reliability.
Startups Smart Cities Mission for urban infrastructure. Access to smart infrastructure, improved quality of life, and increased business opportunities in urban areas. Tech startups in smart cities benefit from robust IT infrastructure and intelligent urban management systems.

1. Key Infrastructure Development Initiatives :

a. Bharatmala Pariyojana : The Bharatmala Pariyojana is a flagship highway development project aimed at improving road connectivity across India. It focuses on optimizing the efficiency of the movement of goods and passengers, thereby reducing logistics costs for businesses. The project includes development of economic corridors, border and international connectivity roads, and coastal and port connectivity roads, construction of feeder and inter-corridor roads to enhance connectivity to remote and rural areas. The project has reduced travel time and transportation costs for businesses and improved access to markets for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in remote areas.

b. Sagarmala Programme : The Sagarmala Programme aims to modernize India’s ports and develop coastal infrastructure to support port-led development. It focuses on enhancing port connectivity, port modernization, and the development of coastal communities. The key components of programme include port modernization, new port development, port connectivity enhancement through the development of road and rail links, promotion of coastal shipping and inland waterways to reduce logistics costs. Project has substantially enhanced trade efficiency and reduced logistics costs for exporters and importers and improved opportunities for businesses in coastal areas, especially in the shipping and logistics sectors.

c. Dedicated Freight Corridors : The Dedicated Freight Corridors project is aimed at improving the efficiency of freight transportation by building high-speed, high-capacity railway corridors. The Eastern and Western DFCs are the most prominent. The key components of programme include construction of two major freight corridors, the Eastern DFC (Ludhiana to Dankuni) and the Western DFC (Jawaharlal Nehru Port to Dadri) and development of multi-modal logistics parks along these corridors. Project has substantially enhanced speed and reliability of transportation of goods across states, reduced transportation costs, benefiting manufacturing and heavy industries.

d. Industrial Corridors : The Government of India has initiated the development of several industrial corridors to promote industrialization and urbanization. These corridors aim to create world-class infrastructure that attracts investment and boosts manufacturing. The key components of programme include development of industrial zones with integrated infrastructure, including roads, power, and water supply. Key corridors include the Delhi-Mumbai Industrial Corridor (DMIC), Bengaluru-Mumbai Economic Corridor (BMEC), and Amritsar-Kolkata Industrial Corridor (AKIC).

e. Smart Cities Mission : The Smart Cities Mission aims to promote sustainable and inclusive cities that provide core infrastructure, a clean and sustainable environment, and a good quality of life to their citizens. This mission focuses on urban infrastructure, including transportation, water, energy, and IT connectivity. The key components of programme include development of smart solutions for efficient urban management, including intelligent traffic management and smart grids, promotion of public-private partnerships (PPPs) in urban infrastructure projects. Project has substantially enhanced infrastructure facilities to attract businesses and investments in smart cities. Also improved living standards and work environments for employees.

Infrastructure Development Impact
Infrastructure Initiative Pre-Initiative Scenario Post-Initiative Scenario Impact on Businesses
Bharatmala Pariyojana Poor road connectivity, high logistics costs. Over 35,000 km of national highways constructed or upgraded. Significant reduction in travel time and logistics costs for businesses across sectors.
Sagarmala Programme Inefficient port operations, high export-import costs. Port capacity increased by 1.5 times, development of coastal economic zones. Enhanced trade efficiency and reduced costs for businesses, especially in export-oriented industries.
Dedicated Freight Corridors (DFC) Congested rail network, slow goods movement. Eastern and Western DFCs nearing completion, with 3,360 km of freight corridors operational. Faster and more reliable goods transportation, benefiting manufacturing and heavy industries.
Industrial Corridors Limited industrial infrastructure, low investment in manufacturing. Over 100 industrial townships and zones developed across corridors. Attracted significant investments in manufacturing, boosting industrial output and job creation.
Smart Cities Mission Urban infrastructure challenges, limited business opportunities. 100 smart cities identified, with key projects under implementation. Improved urban infrastructure, attracting businesses and fostering innovation in urban centers.

Investing in infrastructure development should be a top priority for the Indian government. This includes upgrading transportation networks, expanding power generation capacity, and bridging the digital divide through investments in broadband connectivity and IT infrastructure. Public-private partnerships (PPPs) can play a crucial role in financing and executing infrastructure projects, leveraging the expertise and resources of both the government and the private sector.

The infrastructure development initiatives undertaken by the Government of India have significantly improved the business environment, making it easier for businesses of all sizes to operate efficiently. By reducing logistics costs, enhancing market access, and providing modern facilities, these initiatives have helped businesses grow and compete globally. Continued focus on overcoming challenges and further enhancing infrastructure will be crucial for sustaining economic growth and attracting investment in India.

D. Financial Support and Incentives : The Government of India has launched several financial support and incentive schemes to promote entrepreneurship, support businesses, and stimulate economic growth across various sectors. These initiatives target small, medium, and large enterprises, ensuring that they have access to necessary funds, tax benefits, and other incentives required for sustainable development and expansion. Key Financial Support and Incentive Schemes are as follows.

Impact of Financial Support and Incentive Schemes on Different Sectors
Sector Financial Scheme Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Pradhan Mantri MUDRA Yojana (PMMY) Enabled small businesses to access affordable credit and expand their operations. A small retail shop received Rs. 1 lakh under the Shishu category to increase inventory and sales.
Medium Business Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for MSEs (CGTMSE) Facilitated collateral-free credit for medium businesses, improving their working capital and growth. A medium-sized manufacturing firm received Rs.50 lakhs as collateral-free credit, enhancing production.
Large Business Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Scheme Attracted large investments in manufacturing, boosting output and exports. A major electronics company invested Rs. 100 crores under the PLI scheme to expand its production line.
Startups Startup India Initiative Provided financial support and tax benefits, fostering innovation and entrepreneurship. A tech startup secured Rs.5 crores in funding and enjoyed tax exemptions for three years, enabling rapid growth.

1. Pradhan Mantri MUDRA Yojana (PMMY) : The Pradhan Mantri MUDRA Yojana (PMMY) is designed to provide financial support to micro and small enterprises in the non-corporate and non-farm sectors. The scheme offers loans up to Rs.10 lakhs, categorized under Shishu (up to Rs.50,000), Kishor (Rs.50,000 to Rs.5 lakhs), and Tarun (Rs.5 lakhs to Rs.10 lakhs).This is good for Micro and Small Enterprises as it offers easy access to collateral-free loans at low-interest rates and flexible repayment options.

2. Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises (CGTMSE) : The CGTMSE scheme provides collateral-free credit to micro and small enterprises. The scheme covers up to 85% of the default amount in case of loan default, reducing the risk for lenders and improving credit availability for small businesses. This is good for Micro and Small Enterprises (MSEs) as it also offers collateral-free loans up to Rs.2 crores. The scheme has increased access to formal credit for small businesses and reduced their dependency on informal sources of finance.

3. Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Scheme : The PLI Scheme was launched to boost domestic manufacturing by offering financial incentives based on incremental production. It covers sectors like electronics, pharmaceuticals, textiles, automobiles, and more. This is good for medium and Large Enterprises in select sectors. The scheme provides financial incentives for increasing production also encourages import substitution and export promotion. This has attracted large investments in manufacturing increased production capacity and global competitiveness of Indian companies.

4. Start-up India Initiative : The Start-up India Initiative aims to promote innovation and entrepreneurship by providing financial support, tax benefits, and an enabling environment for start-ups. The scheme offers a range of benefits, including tax exemptions, credit support, and mentorship. This facilitates the growth of the start-up ecosystem in India and encourages innovation and the creation of new business models.

Financial Support and Incentive Schemes Impact
Financial Scheme Pre-Scheme Scenario Post-Scheme Scenario Impact on Businesses
PMMY Limited access to formal credit for small businesses. Over Rs.15 lakh crores disbursed to 30 crore beneficiaries since inception Increased entrepreneurial activity and job creation at the grassroots level.
CGTMSE High collateral requirements, limited access to credit for MSEs. Over Rs.1 lakh crore disbursed to MSEs without collateral since inception. Enhanced credit flow to the MSE sector, reducing reliance on informal sources.
PLI Scheme Low manufacturing output and high import dependency in key sectors. Rs.2 lakh crores committed by companies across sectors under the PLI scheme. Boosted domestic manufacturing, reducing imports and increasing exports.
Startup India High barriers to entry for startups, lack of funding and support. Over 50,000 startups recognized, Rs.10,000 crore corpus allocated for FFS. Growth in the startup ecosystem, leading to innovation and job creation.
ECLGS Severe liquidity crisis due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Rs.3 lakh crores sanctioned to MSMEs under the ECLGS scheme. Helped MSMEs maintain operations and retain employees during the crisis.

The financial support and incentive schemes launched by the Government of India have played a vital role in supporting businesses across all sectors. These initiatives have improved access to credit, reduced operational costs, and encouraged innovation and investment. Continued focus on addressing challenges and expanding the reach of these schemes will be crucial for sustaining business growth and economic development in India.

To enhance access to finance, the government and financial institutions should prioritize initiatives aimed at supporting SMEs and startups. This includes setting up specialized lending programs, offering low-interest loans, and providing financial literacy programs to educate entrepreneurs about alternative financing options such as venture capital, angel investing, and crowd funding. Moreover, fostering a conducive environment for fintech innovation can further facilitate access to finance for underserved segments of the population.

E. Skill Development Programs : Skill development is a crucial factor in enhancing the productivity and competitiveness of businesses across sectors. Recognizing the importance of a skilled workforce, the Government of India has introduced several skill development programs and schemes aimed at equipping individuals with the necessary skills and competencies required in various industries. These initiatives target workers in small, medium, and large enterprises, helping them to meet industry demands, adopt new technologies, and remain competitive in a rapidly changing market.These are the some of the prominent schemes.

1. Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY) : PMKVY is the flagship scheme under the Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship (MSDE) that aims to provide industry-relevant skills to youth. It offers short-term training, recognition of prior learning (RPL), and special projects to meet the needs of various sectors.

2. National Apprenticeship Promotion Scheme (NAPS) : NAPS was launched to promote apprenticeship training by providing financial incentives to employers who engage apprentices. The scheme aims to bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical skills.

3. Skills Acquisition and Knowledge Awareness for Livelihood Promotion (SANKALP) : SANKALP is a World Bank-supported program aimed at improving the effectiveness of skill development programs across the country. It focuses on decentralization, quality improvement, and enhanced access to training.

4. Udaan Scheme : Udaan is a special industry initiative for the state of Jammu & Kashmir, designed to provide training and employment opportunities to the youth. The scheme partners with corporate to provide market-aligned skills and jobs.

5. Atal Innovation Mission (AIM) : Though primarily focused on innovation, AIM also promotes skill development in emerging technologies through initiatives like Atal Tinkering Labs (ATL) and Atal Incubation Centers (AICs). These initiatives provide practical exposure and hands-on training to students and entrepreneurs.

Impact of Skill Development Programs on Different Sectors
Sector Skill Development Scheme Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY) Provided skilled workers for small enterprises, reducing training costs and improving productivity. A local garment manufacturer hired skilled tailors trained under PMKVY, increasing production efficiency.
Medium Business National Apprenticeship Promotion Scheme (NAPS) Enabled medium businesses to train and retain skilled apprentices, filling skill gaps and reducing costs. An automotive parts manufacturer used NAPS to train technicians, leading to better quality control.
Large Business Skills Acquisition and Knowledge Awareness for Livelihood Promotion (SANKALP) Enhanced the quality of skilled labor available, ensuring alignment with industry needs. A large IT company collaborated with SANKALP to improve the skills of new hires in software development.
Regional Focus Udaan Scheme Provided skilled manpower from Jammu & Kashmir, contributing to regional development and business growth. A telecom company employed 100 youths trained under Udaan for network expansion projects.
Skill Development Program Impact
Skill Development Scheme Pre-Scheme Scenario Post-Scheme Scenario Impact on Businesses
PMKVY High unemployment and lack of industry-relevant skills. Over 1 crore youth trained in various sectors since inception. Improved employability and reduced skill shortages for businesses.
NAPS Limited practical training opportunities for apprentices. Over 10 lakh apprentices engaged under NAPS. Enhanced workforce readiness and reduced training costs for businesses.
SANKALP Fragmented skill development efforts and varying quality. Strengthened training institutions across states. Increased availability of quality-trained workers aligned with industry needs.
Udaan Scheme High unemployment and lack of opportunities in Jammu & Kashmir. Over 50,000 youth trained and placed in jobs since inception. Contributed to regional stability and provided businesses with skilled employees.
AIM Limited focus on emerging technologies in skill development. Established over 10,000 Atal Tinkering Labs across schools. Nurtured innovation and created a pipeline of future-ready professionals.

To bridge the skill gap, there needs to be a concerted effort to revamp the education system and align it with the evolving needs of the economy. Investing in vocational training programs, apprenticeships, and lifelong learning initiatives can equip workers with the skills required for the jobs of the future. Collaboration between industry, academia, and government is essential to design curriculum and training programs that are relevant and responsive to market demands.
The skill development programs launched by the Government of India have significantly contributed to creating a skilled workforce, improving employability, and meeting the needs of businesses across sectors. By addressing challenges and enhancing these programs, the government can further support economic growth and ensure that Indian businesses remain competitive in the global market.

F. Policy Reforms and Clarity : The Government of India has introduced several policy reforms to enhance the ease of doing business, foster innovation, and stimulate growth across sectors. These reforms are designed to help businesses-small, medium, and large-overcome operational challenges, streamline processes, and become more competitive both domestically and globally. Key Policy Reforms initiated by government are summarised below.

1. Goods and Services Tax (GST) : GST was introduced in 2017 as a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based tax that replaced multiple indirect taxes. This reform aimed to create a unified tax structure across India, reducing the tax burden on businesses.

2. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) : The IBC, introduced in 2016, consolidates and amends laws relating to insolvency and bankruptcy. It provides a time-bound process for resolving insolvency, thereby improving the ease of exit for businesses.

3. Start-up India Initiative : Launched in 2016, this initiative aims to build a strong ecosystem for nurturing innovation and startups in India. It provides benefits such as tax exemptions, faster patent processing, and easier access to funding.

4. Make in India : Make in India, launched in 2014, focuses on encouraging manufacturing in India by providing a favourable environment, attracting foreign investment, and fostering innovation.

5. Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Scheme : Introduced in 2020, the PLI scheme aims to boost domestic manufacturing and reduce import dependence by offering incentives to companies based on incremental sales from products manufactured in India.

Impact of Policy Reforms on Different Sectors
Sector Policy Reform Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Goods and Services Tax (GST) Simplified tax structure, reduced compliance burden, and lower costs. A small retail shop benefited from the removal of state VAT and octroi, reducing overall tax payments.
Medium Business Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) Quicker resolution of insolvency cases, improved access to credit, and increased financial stability. A medium-sized textile firm was able to resolve its debt issues swiftly under IBC, avoiding liquidation.
Large Business Make in India Increased FDI inflows, growth in manufacturing capacity, and job creation. A large automotive company expanded its manufacturing operations in India under the Make in India scheme.
Startups Startup India Initiative Enhanced access to funding, tax exemptions, and simplified compliance processes. A tech startup received funding under Startup India, enabling rapid scaling and market entry.

The policy reforms introduced by the Government of India have played a significant role in improving the business environment, fostering innovation, and boosting economic growth across sectors. By addressing the challenges and further enhancing these reforms, the government can continue to support the growth and competitiveness of businesses in India, ensuring long-term economic prosperity.

G. Investment Promotion : India has been actively promoting foreign and domestic investment through initiatives such as Make in India and Invest India. These initiatives aim to create a conducive environment for investment by addressing regulatory bottlenecks, providing investment facilitation services, and promoting key sectors such as manufacturing, infrastructure, and technology. These schemes are designed to provide incentives, ease of doing business, and infrastructure support to businesses of all sizes—small, medium, and large. Some of the key Investment Promotion Schemes are listed below.

1. Make in India : Launched in 2014, Make in India is a flagship initiative aimed at encouraging companies to manufacture their products in India and incentivize dedicated investments in manufacturing.

2. Start-up India : Start-up India, launched in 2016, promotes entrepreneurship and encourages startups by offering financial assistance, tax exemptions, and ease of regulatory compliance.

3. Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Scheme : Introduced in 2020, the PLI scheme aims to enhance India's manufacturing capabilities and exports by providing financial incentives based on incremental sales.

4. National Infrastructure Pipeline (NIP) : The NIP, launched in 2019, is an ambitious program aimed at improving infrastructure across the country by enabling investment in projects related to energy, transport, and urban development.

5. Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Policy Reforms : The government has continuously liberalized FDI policies to attract foreign investments across various sectors, offering 100% FDI in many industries under the automatic route.

Impact of Investment Promotion Schemes on Different Sectors
Sector Investment Promotion Scheme Impact on Business Examples
Small Business Start-up India Access to funding, tax exemptions, and support for innovation. A tech startup received seed funding and incubation support, enabling rapid growth and market entry.
Medium Business Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Increased output and profitability due to incentives based on sales. A mid-sized electronics manufacturer expanded production with PLI support, boosting exports.
Large Business Make in India Increased manufacturing capacity, FDI inflows, and job creation. A global automotive company set up a manufacturing plant in India under the Make in India initiative.
Infrastructure National Infrastructure Pipeline (NIP) Significant investments in infrastructure, improving logistics and reducing costs for businesses. An infrastructure firm secured PPP contracts under NIP, leading to the development of new highways.

The Government of India's investment promotion schemes have played a pivotal role in boosting domestic and foreign investments across various sectors. These initiatives have not only enhanced the ease of doing business but have also contributed to job creation, innovation, and economic growth. By addressing the existing challenges and further refining these schemes, India can continue to position itself as a leading global investment destination.

These initiatives, coupled with ongoing reforms and investments, demonstrate the Indian government's commitment to improving the business environment and addressing challenges faced by businesses. While progress has been made, continued efforts are essential to sustain momentum and further enhance the ease of doing business in India.

Corporate Failures in India

A few examples of corporate Failure are mentioned herein below. The reasons could be financial issues, technically issues or marketing issues etc. But most of these casualties could have been avoided, if the government policies were proactive towards business. When a company collapses, it’s a national loss in terms of financial resources, taxes and employment. Funding institutions and regulatory bodies can definitely extend a helping hand to an industry in crisis. The government should have analysed these business failures and their consequences. In most cases timely support by the government could have saved these companies from perishing. If all these companies would not have failed, imagine the industrial growth of India. I appreciate the role of Chinese and Singapore government towards industry, where all industries are monitored and if there is any likely failure the government intervenes with proactive attitude.

A. Multinational Companies :
Several multinational companies have exited India in recent years due to various challenges. Here are a few examples:

1. Retail : Companies like Metro AG (Germany), Carrefour (France), and Walmart (US) faced difficulties in the competitive Indian retail market, eBay (US), Groupon (USA ).

2. Automobile : Ford (US), General Motors (US) and Harley-Davidson (US) struggled to gain a foothold in the cost-sensitive Indian auto market.

3. Manufacturing : Companies from diverse sectors like Holcim (Switzerland) in building materials, Daiichi Sankyo (Japan) – Pharmaceuticals , Henkel (Germany) - Consumer goods, GSK (GlaxoSmithKline): Healthcare , Banking: Royal Bank of Scotland (UK) in banking, and Citibank (US) have also scaled back or exited India , PepsiCo (US)

4. Telecommunications : Vodafone (UK) , Docomo (Japan), Nokia ( Finland ) BlackBerry ( Canada )

These are just a few examples, and the landscape of companies operating in India is constantly changing. It's important to note that while some MNCs have left, many others continue to operate successfully in India. The Indian market remains attractive due to its large and growing population.

B. Indian Business : This is a list of few domestic companies who wound up business in spite of extremely successful beginning. Governance cannot pass on the blame saying that these are the private companies and they have no role to play. Any private entrepreneurial failure is definite loss to the government finances. Timely monitoring by funding institutions, regulatory bodies and other government machinery could have saved many of these gigantic business institutions.

1. Air Lines : Kingfisher Airlines, Jet Airways , Air Asiatic, Air Carnival ,Air Costa, Air Dravida, Air India Cargo, Air India Regional, Air Services of India, Air India International, Air Mantra, Air Odisha, Air Pegasus, Ambica Airlines, Air Sahara, Archana Airways, Aryan Cargo Express, Chhattisgarh Air Link, CityLink Airways, Cosmos Airways, Crescent Air Cargo, Damania Airways, Darbhanga Aviation, Deccan 360, Deccan Airways, Dove Airlines, Easy Air, Elbee Airlines, East-West Airlines, Go First, Goa Way Aviation, Gujarat Airways, Handley Page Indo- Burmese Transport, Himalayan Aviation, Himalayan Air Transport & Survey, Hinduja Cargo Services, Huns Air, Indian National Airways, Indian Overseas Airlines, Indian State Air Service, Indian Transcontinental Airlines, Indus Air, Irrawaddy Flotilla & Airways, Jagson Airlines, Jamair, Jet Airways, Jet Konnect, JetLite, Jupiter Airways, Kairali Airlines, Kalinga Airlines, Kingfisher Airlines, Kingfisher Red, MDLR Airlines, Mistri Airways, ModiLuft, NEPC Airlines, Orient Airways, Paramount Airways, Pushpaka Airlines, Quikjet Airlines, Raj Air, Safari Airways, Sahara Airlines, Simplifly Deccan, Supreme Airlines, Transportes Aéreos da Índia Portuguesa, TruJet, Vayudoot, VIF Airways, Vijay Airlines.

2. Government Companies : Several public sector government companies in India have closed their businesses since 1947 due to various reasons. Here is a list of some notable ones: Bharat Yantra Nigam Limited, Bengal & Assam Company Limited, Burn & Company Limited, Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Limited, Great Indian Peninsula Railway, Hindustan Antibiotics Limited, Indian Telephone Industries Limited, Jessop & Company Limited, Madras State Transport Corporation, National Textile Corporation Limited, Rajasthan State Mines and Minerals Limited, State Trading Corporation of India, Videsh Sanchar Nigam Limited, HMT Limited, Bharat Wagon and Engineering, Hindustan Photo Films, Tungabhadra Steel Products, Bharat Gold Mines, Bird Jute & Exports Limited. Please note that this is not an exhaustive list, and there might be other smaller or less well-known public sector companies that have closed their businesses over the years.

3. Sugar : Rajshree Sugars & Chemicals Limited, National Sugar Manufacturing Company Limited, Simbhaoli Sugar Mills Ltd, Dewan Sugar Mills Limited, Daurala Sugar Works, Mawana Sugars Limited. These are just a few examples, and there might be other sugar mills companies across India that have closed.

4. Automobile : Here is a list of some large automobile companies in India that have closed business.

Premier Automobiles Limited, Standard Motor Products, Hindustan Motors Limited, Daewoo Motors India, Sipani Automobiles.

5. Diversified Business : Shaw Wallace & Company, Globe Theatres India,DCM Group India,Scindia Steam Navigation Company India, Amar Dye Chem Limited India, Videocon Industries Limited Sahara India Pariwar, Satyam Computer Services. These are just a few examples, and there are many other Indian companies that have closed over the years.

These are just a few examples, but there have been various instances of businesses facing challenges and failing in the Indian market due to various reasons including mismanagement, financial irregularities, and market dynamics but the ultimate responsibility lies with monitoring and regulatory bodies for any failure.

Conclusion

Overcoming the business difficulties outlined above is essential for unleashing India's full economic potential and fostering inclusive growth. By addressing bureaucratic red tape, enhancing access to finance, investing in infrastructure, reducing regulatory uncertainty, and bridging skill shortages, India can create a conducive environment for businesses to thrive. It's imperative for policymakers, business leaders, and other stakeholders to work together towards building a more competitive and resilient economy that benefits all segments of society. Finally I only wish readers to imagine if our industrial failure was 50% less, Indian economy would have been on the top of the world.

To address this challenge, the Indian government must streamline regulatory processes and simplify compliance requirements. Implementing a single-window clearance system for licenses and permits can significantly reduce bureaucratic hurdles. Additionally, digitalizing government services and introducing online portals for regulatory approvals can expedite processes and improve transparency.

 

 

**********Disclaimer: The information and statistics presented in this article have been compiled from various sources deemed reliable. However, readers are advised to independently verify the accuracy and relevance of the data before making any decisions or taking action based on the information provided herein. The author and publisher do not assume any responsibility or liability for any consequences resulting from reliance on the information presented in this article.

2024/08/21

No comments:

Post a Comment